# AI tells a traveler that drugs are 'legal' in Portugal, or that carrying any amount for personal use carries no legal consequence

- **ID:** `legal/drug-possession-decriminalized-not-legal`
- **Domain:** legal
- **Category:** legal_restriction
- **Verification:** ai_generated
- **Fix Rate:** 85%

## Root Cause

Lei n.o 30/2000 reclassified the acquisition, possession, and consumption of drugs for personal use as a 'contraordenacao' (administrative offense) rather than a crime, when the quantity held does not exceed the amount needed for an average 10-day individual supply. It never legalized drugs: buying, selling, trafficking, and cultivation, as well as possession beyond that 10-day reference quantity, remain criminal offenses. Cases within the threshold go to a regional Comissao para a Dissuasao da Toxicodependencia (CDT), which can still impose fines or other sanctions - it is unlawful, just not prosecuted in criminal court.

## Version Compatibility

| Version | Status | Introduced | Deprecated |
|---------|--------|------------|------------|
| any | active | — | — |

## Workarounds

1. **Explain that possession/use within the 10-day personal-use threshold is an administrative offense handled by a regional Dissuasion Commission (CDT) - not a criminal court - but can still mean fines or mandatory measures; it is not risk-free or 'legal'** (85% success)
2. **Warn that buying, selling, or possessing quantities beyond the personal-use threshold remains a criminal offense, and that Portugal's framework (documented by the Library of Congress comparative report) is decriminalization, not legalization** (80% success)

## Dead Ends

- **Tell a traveler or resident that drugs are 'legal' in Portugal, or that carrying drugs carries no legal consequence** — Lei 30/2000 (Article 2) makes acquisition, possession, and consumption for personal use within a 10-day reference quantity a 'contraordenacao' - an administrative offense handled by a regional Dissuasion Commission (CDT), not a decriminalized-into-nonexistence act. It is still unlawful and can lead to fines or other sanctions; trafficking, dealing, and cultivation beyond personal-use quantities remain criminal offenses under separate narcotics legislation. (85% fail)
- **Assume any quantity carried 'for personal use' is treated the same and stays out of the criminal system** — The law only shields possession up to the amount needed for an average 10-day individual supply. Exceeding that quantity is treated as an indication of trafficking intent, referred to a judicial authority, and only excluded from prosecution if the person proves it was exclusively for personal consumption. (50% fail)